Large Cap ETF v/s Mid Cap ETF: Historical Performance Check: Finance Trading Times

Large Cap ETF v/s Mid Cap ETF: Historical Performance Check

We've been giving a lot of advice about investing in ETF or Exchange Traded Funds. Here is an Example of Nifty based ETF. Some readers have also asked questions about whether they should go for Large Cap based ETF like the Nifty or Sensex based ETF or should they go for the Mid cap based ETF. Then there are some more investors who may look for much larger diversification, but with the benefits of ETF, so how has that performed?

In this article, we will look at the historical performance of the large cap ETF, mid cap ETF and much more diversified ETF from Benchmark ETF funds. The data provided is taken from the PDF that Benchmark funds have provided and the methodology is that used by Benchmark ETFs while making the calculations. The purpose of this article is NOT to advertise for Benchmark ETF, but to draw a comparison between Large Cap, Mid cap and diversified performance. Since the ETF's reflect the performance of the underlying index, their performance also give a very good analysis of whether you should go for large caps or mid caps or diversified funds. All data taken is as of February 27, 2009.

So here is the Historical Performance of Nifty Bees, the ETF based on Nifty 50 or the top 50 stocks of NSE as per market capitalization.
NiftyBees ETF Historical Performance
Returns for less than 1 year are absolute and more than one year are compounded annualized.
As we can observe in the data presented above by the Benchmark ETF, over a 5 year horizon NiftyBees ETF claims to provide a 10.67% annualized compounded returns.

Now, have a look at the Historical Performance of JuniorBees or the top 51 to 100 stocks of NSE as per the market capitalization.
JuniorBees ETF Historical Performance
Seeing the 5 year horizon, the annualized compunded returns from JuniorBees has been a mere 4.09 percent. Hence, over the long period, the Large Cap returns have outperformed the mid cap returns.

Related: SBI GETS-SBI Gold ETF NFO Review: SBI Gold Exchange Traded Scheme & Gold ETF: Historical Performance of Gold ETF & Gold ETF India

To cross-check, let's have a look at the data provided for the underlying index i.e. the Nifty 50 returns and the Nifty Junior Returns. If you compare the 5 year annualized compounded returns of the underlying benchmark index, you will see that the Nifty junior has provided a return of just 3.63% while Nifty 50 has provided a return of 8.94 percent.

Now this should be a sufficient sign for people who firmly believe that only Mid caps are the real winners and they may outperform the large caps. Well, that's not the case as you can see above.
Have Comments or Questions? Please post them as comments using "Post our Comments" link below. Your queries will be responded for free in 24 hrs!

2 Comments: Post your Comments

Neil said...(on 5 May 2009 at 08:54 )  

Shobhit,
Your advise for going NIFTY based ETF really makes sense.
I have been dabbling in stock markets for more 3 years. I have been assessing possibility of entering into stock markets as a full time profession.
Since you are qualified finance professional and have practical experience of stock markets, I would like to ask following queries.
1) How easy or difficult it is to make a leaving out of stock markets? either by trading or by investments.
2) I have a fairly stable [at least i think so as of now..:-) ] IT job. how practical it would be to get into stock markets?
3) Can one make leaving out of passive index investing?
4) How safe do you think index futures are? Can one make a living on it?
5)In index futures, at the end of 3 months period, if I am still in loss in index futures, can I renew /extend the future/contract? or does the contract necessarily expire and I have to accept it even if I have suffered loss?
6)You advise ETF investing. Do you think index futures is equally safe as ETF investing or is it riskier?

Sathya said...(on 1 May 2011 at 04:02 )  

Hi,

I recently landed in your blog when i was searching for some articles on Insurance. I really like your blogs.They are very informative. Could you write on comparision between returns from ETF and Mutual funds. I dint see an article on that yet on your blog. Is it better to invest as SIP in ETF's or a 5 star mutual fund. Please advice.

Thanks
Sathya

Wish you all happy and fruitful trading and investing activities with safety! = = = Post a Comment

Copyright Information:
© Finance-Trading-Times.com
Please see Our Copy Right Policy. All the articles, posts and other materials on this website/blog are copyrighted to the owners of this portal. The content should NOT to be reproduced on any other website or through other medium, without the author's AND owners' permission. Contact: contactus(AT)finance-trading-times.com

DISCLAIMER: Before using this site, you agree to the Disclaimer. For Any questions or comments, please mail contactus(AT)finance-trading-times.com.

About UsAdvertise with UsCopyRight Policy & Fair Use GuidePrivacy PolicyDisclaimer